Arnold's Restaurant until it closed in September 2010.
The last we heard of what might be happening in that space was in December 2011, when the owner of 2nd Story Counseling told us that: "We have been told by the landlord that some type of a bar and/or
restaurant is moving into the space below our offices sometime in the
early part of 2012. ... The
owners of this space would be the same folks who operated the Green
So Don and Sam Menetti, the owners of the Green Dolphin Street jazz club, as well as Lawrence House, 4526 Sheridan, and other Housing Court mainstays were going to open a bar there? When we saw the liquor license request, we looked to see who might be behind it. Nothing on the Public Notice about that.
So off we went to the City of Chicago website to see the names of entities filing liquor licenses in the past six weeks. And there it was:
So not a Menetti, then? Wait, not so fast.
A little Googling shows that the Menetti brothers are also known as the Mehmeti brothers. In fact, Burim Mehmeti is named as a defendant in the foreclosure papers filed by FirstMerit Bank against Lawrence House, Astor House, and the other properties owned by the family.
So, it's a shocker to us that the Menetti family would want to do any more business in the 46th Ward, but ... there you have it. Is Uptown ready for another Green Dolphin Street?
We are dubious, and not just because of the negligence with which they have treated their residential tenants at Lawrence House and 4526 N Sheridan. Green Dolphin Street has also had a troubled history under the Menettis'/Mehmetis' ownership, including several instances of violence. We are very aware that Lawrence House's many issues, problematic to both its residents and the community, only began to be resolved when the court ordered that the Menettis turn it over to the management of a receiver.
There's an extensive article in the Inside-Booster from last March that details the plans for the new club at Irving Park and Broadway, and also goes into the problems experienced under the Menettis' ownership and management of the Green Dolphin and the residential buildings.